Sat 29 Sep 2007
The Silent City
Posted by Ricardo under Reviews
No Comments

I “discovered” The Silent City while reminiscing through Vengaboys videoclips on Vuze. In retrospect that was, perhaps, an unfortunate association. But at least now I can say I have something to thank Vengaboys for. Other than the “Up & Down” clip, that is.
The Silent City is a 2006, 7-minute short by Ruairi Robinson, who was nominated for a short-feature Oscar in 2002. I was never really into short films. Yes yes, I’m a hypocrite, there’ll always be GTV, etc., but I always felt shortchanged with short films. Silent City really made me appreciate what’s good about a short: the demands on a filmmaker are far greater. Efficiency is a greater constraint over effectiveness. This makes highly-effective shorts incredibly rare. I can only think of one other short which elicited the same sort of awe for film making that Silent City did, Mark Osborne’s More.
Robinson’s short starts with 3 soldiers in the outskirts of post-apocalyptic city. Because it’s well, short, I’d rather not tell you more than that. I have to say that the combination of scene composition, incredible and deftly-purposed CGI and a short, impacting story make The Silent City one of those movies you want to show to film students and tell them: “See? There is no causation between length of film and degree of impact. You don’t need to agonize hours over plot development to make an impact. You can have your cake and eat it too, but it’s not easy: pulling that off is what makes you a master pastry chef.”
I also have to expand on the CGI in the movie. Watching a shot and then seeing how it was composed was incredible. Some films, like Sky Captain and the World of Tomorrow, have done this as well, but the difference is striking: Sky Captain and other “digital lot” features use 100% CGI. The result is an almost Pixar-like stylization, where you know that every single thing in the shot other than the actors is CGI. The Silent City is far more refined in its use of CGI–far better than other digital lot attempts, and surprisingly manages to leap the “soundstage uncanny valley“.
This is a great piece of film-making and I’m glad I found it. And did I mention Cillian Murphy is one of the three soldiers?
As an added bonus to anyone who’s got a nice laptop or beefy desktop, this short is available in HD. You can download the whopping 146MB file from the director’s site or using BitTorrent though the link at the bottom.
(via Vuze)









